Today’s Fad or Tomorrow’s Future?
Educational Leadership Program
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
What is the problem?
In present day world of hastily expanding technology, education is
struggling to keep abreast. The task that the education gadget
faces is a way to provide expanded learning possibilities and maximize
technology with the constraint of restricted funding. Distance mastering
emerged on the instructional scene in the form of correspondence
guides and has evolved at a rapid tempo consistent with the expanding
era of the beyond two a long time. It provides numerous possibilities
to amplify instructional possibilities in K-12 schools. However,
distance getting to know has many critics who maintain that it isn’t
as powerful as face-to-face interaction in a lecture room. Despite
the above grievance, distance getting to know is growing in recognition
and facility and therefore is a trend that begs in addition investigation.
The cause of this paper is to describe the heritage of distance
training, examine the forces riding the issue, where it is going
in public colleges, its implications for public education, and
what movements we advocate to educational leaders vis-a-vis the use of
distance learning in public education.
Background and Context
Distance gaining knowledge of has been defined in numerous approaches. Virginia
Steiner states: “distance learning is educational transport
that allows the pupil to be in a separate geographical place
from the trainer” (May 1996,
p.1). The U. S. Office of Technology Assessment defines distance
getting to know because the “linking of a instructor and students in numerous
geographic locations thru era that lets in for interaction”
(Cartwright, 1994). Edward F. Spodick,
of the Hong Kong University of Science and Technology believes
that a customary definition of distance studying isn’t as critical
as the prospect of “improved academic possibilities offered
for broader segments of the population, while accommodating unique
conditions and wishes.” The definitions range however the crucial
subject matter echoes the idea of distance gaining knowledge of as off-site content
Distance studying has been in existence in numerous modes when you consider that
the start of correspondence courses within the 1800’s. Historically
its primary purpose turned into to transmit statistics among people
in one of a kind places. The evolution of distance gaining knowledge of, following
a modest lineage, is currently experiencing a trajectory with
expeditious innovations in technological development.
Written correspondence-Since the creation of written language,
statistics and ideas had been transmitted among humans. This
extended with the growth of technology such as the printing
press, the establishment of early colleges and the development
of postal delivery offerings.
Audio-conferencing-The invention of the cellphone enabled instructors
and college students to proportion thoughts. The generation became simple. The modern
technology of the time became hooking up cellphone lines and a voice
field to transmit -manner conversations across terrific distances.
Telecommunication-In the 1950’s the television created a new form
of school room. Many secondary schools and universities taught classes
through tv. These instructions had been either one-way lectures or
Information Superhighway-The beyond decade is characterized through swiftly
expanding era which has substantially multiplied the scope of
educational opportunities to be had for distance schooling. Computers,
CD-ROM, laptop networks and the World Wide Web have played an
critical role in bridging distance gaps all through america and
Tools for Distance Learning
The form of generation utilized is a key issue of powerful
distance training. However, the desires of the inexperienced persons, requirements
of the content, and the instructional obstacles need to be taken into consideration
before deciding on a delivery machine. A systematic and included
technique is the quality technique to hire a combination of educational media.
The four fundamental technological mediums to transmit distance getting to know
are voice, video, computer, and print. An powerful distance education
course must encompass a combination of media, every serving a specific
reason. An example follows:
- A strong print aspect is needed to provide the simple content
of the path. This consists of a cautiously selected text as well as
an prepared syllabus, magnificence outlines and supplementary readings.
- Interactive audio and video conferencing allows college students to
talk with every different and the trainer. This is likewise an
ideal way to comprise guest speakers and students.
- Electronic mail can be used to update assignments, make clear
questions, provide set off comments and permit college students to react
and comment on every others paintings.
- Pre-recorded video tapes is an effective technique for assessment
and to make certain that absent students have the opportunity to stay
present day of their work. Tapes also can facilitate the continuity
of the gaining knowledge of process when and if an instructor is temporarily
unavailable to fulfill with his or her magnificence.
- Fax can distribute assignments, make ultimate minute changes,
acquire assignments and checks, and offer activate comments.
- The World Wide Web, in combination with other Internet gear,
permits instructors and college students to access a huge range of assets
to facilitate a innovative and interactive gaining knowledge of environment.
There are a number of forces using the growth in distance
learning methodologies in public training.
Rate of Technological Change-The acceleration of technological
improvement is having an great impact on distance training.
A collection of interoperable systems able to transmitting
statistics, textual content, pics, voice and video are available and are getting
increasingly more low-priced. Many states are funding massive-scale records
systems that offer get right of entry to to these networks, together with North Carolina’s Information Highway
. These networks are constantly being better to fulfill user requirements
because the era is evolved.
Optimal Learning Conditions-Economic constraints hinder our
capability to provide essential resources for best gaining knowledge of situations.
All districts can get right of entry to critical data to fulfill the needs
of a numerous student populace. Distance training can decrease
geographic boundaries and might facilitate conversation past regional
and country wide barriers to promote accelerated instructional interplay.
The critical directive to train greater humans with confined or declining
assets, with out decreasing standards can be realized.
Demands of Business and Industry-Since the early days of education
reform, economic leaders have criticized schools for failing to
produce a competitive team of workers. Complaints include charges that
college students lack many basic skills which include enjoy with new
technology. Many agencies are infusing cash into the schools
to improve education and often those dollars are earmarked for
system and instructor education in new generation. Businesses are
willing to allocate money and time to develop efforts centered
at enhancing the coaching of the destiny workforce.
Interactive Educational Experiences-There is little debate
that most college students have end up disengaged from the typical excessive
college curriculum. Constructivist theories declare that accelerated
mastering happens when students are actively worried and interested
in their schooling. Distance schooling technologies inspire
students to be energetic of their mastering technique. For example,
interactive technology allow students a long way greater possibilities
to have interaction in studies methods than is currently to be had in
most traditional getting to know environments.
Diverse Social Awareness-The publicity to the evolving “international
village” is hastily advancing because of media and technology.
Today’s pupil populace will want to be snug in a world
of expanding range. Distance mastering exposes college students to
our substantial and ever increasing universe and permits college students to work
with students in different cultures the world over.
At gift, distance getting to know is utilized by a extensive-range of groups
for lots of purposes. Businesses have integrated the era
into team of workers development and training programs. Hospitals, churches
and different groups are capable of link to different establishments. Community
resources consisting of arts councils and homework hotlines can be easily
accessed. The maximum rapidly growing sector the usage of distance gaining knowledge of
era is K-12 education. A 1996 have a look at by way of the Department of
Education carried out a survey on superior telecommunications, such as
distance mastering, in public schools. The effects, primarily based on voluntary
responses from 37% of those solicited, imply that almost a
zone of K-12 public colleges are engaging in some type of telecommunication
inside the study room. The effects, additionally display that huge, rural faculties
within the southeast have the best quantity of hobby in implementing
and maintaining applications utilizing superior era.
Table 1: Percent of Public Schools Using Distance Learning,
by using School Characteristics
Characteristic of School
Percentage Using Distance Learning
All Public Schools22
Size of Enrollment
Less than 300
three hundred to 999
1000 or more
US Department of Education, National Center for Educational Statistics,
Fast Response Survey System. (1996). Survey on advanced telecommunication
in public faculties, fall 1996, FRSS 61, Washington, DC: US
Department of Education.
Benefits and Challenges of Distance Learning
It is projected that the range of colleges imposing distance
mastering will boom because the positive effects of getting to know opportunities
are found out. There are many advantages to distance training
but also many correlating demanding situations. Both aspects of the ledger
need to be examined and addressed as faculties make choices to
healthy their local resources, audience, and institutional
philosophy. Schools systems presenting distance training packages
need to awareness on what nice fits their unique venture, dreams,
and occasions. For every capability advantage, their is also a
perceived mission. For instance, one of the maximum widely accepted
advantages of distance studying is that it will increase publicity
to grasp teachers and specialized publications. Small faculty districts
with confined resources can offer a small group of college students Advanced
Placement courses, quite specialised vocational courses, or unique
foreign languages. The corresponding task is that courses
taught thru network are not cognizant of the natural integument
of the man or woman schools. Furthermore, instructors and unions may additionally
understand using distance learning as a danger to jobs, if
it isn’t made clean that the motive isn’t always to replace teachers
with technology. Distance gaining knowledge of programs are a really perfect manner to
utilize advanced technology and reveal students to a innovative
and interactive studying environment. However, if now not carefully
built, the content of the path may be overpowered as a substitute
than augmented by using the available sources consisting of laptop pix
and the World Wide Web. Therefore, distance gaining knowledge of packages
need to be designed to complement the school room revel in and
decorate mastering possibilities even as recognizing the obstacles.
Table 2: Benefits and Challenges of Distance Education
Exposes extra college students to master teachers
Threatens perceived task protection
Provides get entry to to guides in any other case not to be had
Neglects precise cultural environments if man or woman schools
Encourages instructor collaboration and teaming
Requires paradigm shift of instructor roles and schooling
Promotes training reform and interplay among business, training, and generation
Demands imaginative and prescient to develop strategies for education, implementation, and evaluation
Introduces college students to rising generation
Diminishes awareness on content to generation
Assists with accomplishing unique population
Lacks head to head interplay
Implications for Public Education
Implications for Key Players
Creating an powerful distance studying software does not occur
with out tough work and without the constant and incorporated efforts
of several key players in the educational agency. Below
is a list of the important thing players are and the position every role must
- Students – Because the training in distance studying takes place
shape a distant point, college students omit out on opportunities to have interaction
with instructors and different college students or percentage their backgrounds. They
can most effective depend on “technical linkages to bridge the distance keeping apart
class participant” (Cartwright, 1994). It will become the pupil’s
responsibility so that you can compare and internalize the training
being offered in order that learning can arise. It also allows the
scholar to self-pick out areas of hobby for similarly investigation.
- Faculty – The faculty is accountable for the success (or lack)
of the space training application. Distance gaining knowledge of produces
several demanding situations to instructors because the instructors ought to determine
the desires of remote college students with out face-to-face touch. It
is hard to evolve teaching patterns in order to meet the wishes
of the diverse target audience, mainly whilst huge geographical areas
are worried. In addition, instructors should be able to efficaciously
balance the capability to supply the era and attention on the
position of the teacher concurrently.
- Facilitators – The facilitator plays a crucial position because
he/she acts because the bridge connecting the teacher to the scholar.
Not handiest are facilitators liable for “putting in device,
gathering assignments, proctoring checks, and appearing as the trainer’s
on-website eyes and ears” (Cartwright, 1994), facilitators are
also required to follow via with the instructor’s directions
and expectations for the scholars.
- Support Staff – Better known as the “glue that maintains
the space schooling attempt collectively and on course,” (Trier,
1996) the aid personnel ought to paintings hard to sign up college students,
replica and distribute substances, order textbooks and time table
centers, at the same time as preserving music of grade reports for each student.
- Administrators – Effective distance education administrators
paintings hard to “build consensus, make decisions, and act as
referees, even as operating with technical and help carrier employees
to make certain that the technological assets are effectively deployed
to in addition the group’s educational undertaking” (Trier, 1996).
It is important for administrators to hold in consistent contact
with the facilitators which will keep the educational goals
of each school.
Preparing for the Future: Instructional Development for Distance
Technology is merely an enabler. However, what it allows is not anything
much less than human people, businesses, and cultures, newly
empowered to evolve to compete in this new worldwide climate. In
order for a hit distance mastering applications to be implemented,
we provide the following recommendations for K-12 schools:
View distance mastering as an possibility to revitalize and
innovate present day curricular packages. Advanced telecommunications
era lets in educators to beautify the school room revel in
with new visible and audio media. Graphics, CD-ROM, and programs
from the World Wide Web can be without problems integrated to beautify
mastering possibilities and goals.
Initiate a multi-degree application assessment. Incorporate summative
and formative evaluation to assess and improve programs. Conduct
surveys of student and college delight to check along side
qualitative research on elevated performance. Results of all
evaluation can be used proactively for improvement of present day
Keep the generation transparent. Take warning to ensure that
the content material does no longer wander off in the era. An orientation
program can familiarize participants with the technology in the
early stages so that the era isn’t a distraction to the
gaining knowledge of method. On the alternative hand, in reality the use of the generation
as a way to transmit lecture could be a gross misuse as a distance
getting to know is a useful resource, now not a replacement for the teacher.
Gain inner and outside acclaim for distance studying
programs. Change is regularly met with ambivalence if all stakeholders
are not allowed a voice in the method (Fullan, 1993). Gain the
assist of the students and workforce. Market achievements and spread
the word to different agencies.
Conduct a wishes evaluation. The first step in the implementation
technique must involve input shape a cross-practical crew of teachers,
academic designers, era workforce and students. Identify
and cope with any wishes or issues previous to handing over the first
distance studying program. It is a long way more green to build the
guide into the machine rather than add on at a later date.
Use on-site coordination. One of the important thing players in a success
implementation is the facilitator. The coordinator need to be professional
in the usage of the era, trying out all gadget, and troubleshooting.
Organization skills are crucial as distribution of path material,
touch with the initiating web page, and conversation are fundamental
to easy operation.
Obtain nearby dedication. Prior to venture a distance mastering
software, get dedication from administrators, legislators, and
neighborhood servers to keep the program for a pre-determined time.
Make sure instructors are well-educated. The imperative consciousness
of any distance gaining knowledge of program need to be knowledge in teaching.
Take benefit of master teachers and people with unique capabilities
but also ensure that people get hold of right training and help
with shipping techniques and incorporation of interactive relationships
between the generation, content and those.
Design packages for distance getting to know. Plan cautiously and
meticulously whilst designing a distance studying software. Classes
should include a stability among human interaction and technical
“props” to beautify the educational experience. Charts,
pictures and video components have to beautify classroom sports
which include function-playing, case studies and discussion classes. Student
interplay and participation ought to no longer be unnoticed.
Use dependable system and stay abreast of the modern day technolgy.
Establishing a distance getting to know lab costs an anticipated $80,000
with a further fee of $23 for an hour of air time. It is
high priced however also important that corners are not shaved and modern-day
generation is integrated.
Fad or Future?
Distance studying is not a fad. Distance mastering is right here. Every
educator needs to take the initiative to marketing campaign for comprehensive
education on-site with a view to facilitate professional know-how
and effective pupil consequences. Distance getting to know is main us
to the destiny and the destiny is distributed mastering.
Distributed mastering is rooted in the idea of dispensed resources.
This educational version leads us in the direction of equitable distribution
of tutorial experiences. It allows for the instructor, pupil,
and content material to be positioned in distinct, non-centralized locations
so that training and learning arise impartial of time and
place. This version can create lecture rooms starting from the traditional
to the wholly digital.
As World Wide Web technologies end up extra sophisticated and the
bandwidth of the Internet will increase, the fashion will provide greater
equipment and extra alternatives in developing creative getting to know environments.
The splendor of all that is that for the reason that Internet is based totally on
wellknown communications protocols, we will ensure that students
having access to the Internet in Maine will be able to get entry to the same
assets as the students in Texas.
Beare, P.L. (1989). The comparative effectiveness of videotape,
audiotape, and telelecture in handing over persevering with instructor training.
American Journal of Distance Education. three:2, 57-sixty six.
Blanchard, W. (1989). Telecourse effectiveness: A research-review
replace. Olympia, WA: Washington State Board for Community
College Education. (ED 320 554).
Brooksfield, S.D. (1990). The skillful trainer: On technique,
believe, and responsiveness inside the lecture room. San Francisco,
Cartwright, G.P. (1994, July/August). Distance Learning: A different
time, a distinct vicinity. Change, 26:4, 64-seventy two.
Fullan, M., (1993). Change forces. Bristol, PA
Graham, S.W., & Wedman, J.F. (1989). Enhancing the enchantment
of teletraining. Journal of Instructional Psychology, sixteen:4,
Holmberg, B. (1985). Communication in distance look at. In Status
and tendencies of distance training. Lund, Sweden: Lector Publishing.
Moore, M.G., & Thompson, M.M., with Quigley, A.B., Clark,
G.C., & Goff, G.G. (1990). The effects of distance getting to know:
A summary of the literature. Research Monograph No. 2. University
Par, PA: The Pennsylvania State University, American Center for
the Study of Distance Education. (ED 330 321).
Spodick, E. (1995). The evolution of distance gaining knowledge of.
[On-line]. Available: http://www.fwl.org/hyper_discussions/dlfaq/001.html.
Steiner, V. (1996).What is distance schooling? [On-line].
Steven Salzberg and Susan Polyson. Distributed gaining knowledge of on
the sector extensive net. Virginia Commonwealth University. Reprinted
from Syllabus, volume 9, no 1, 10-12, September 1995. [On-line].
Trier, V. (1996). Distance education: An overview. [On-line].
United States Distance Learning Association (USDLA), (1996, January
26). Distance getting to know truth sheet. [On-Line]. Available:
Willis, B. (1993). Distance education: A realistic guide.
Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications.